The Federal Reserve’s October meeting was a pause, not a pivot. Minutes of the October 27-28 meeting, released on Wednesday, November 18, show that almost all officials judged further interest-rate increases would likely be appropriate — and a couple went further, saying a move larger than 25 basis points could be considered in December if inflation data disappointed. With the October inflation reports now in hand, that condition looks closer to being met.
A 10-2 Vote That Understated the Hawkishness
The Federal Open Market Committee voted 10-2 on October 28 to hold the federal funds rate at 3.75% to 4.00%. Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack dissented, preferring a quarter-point increase at the meeting. But support for tightening extended well beyond the two dissenters.
“Some participants favored an increase of 25 basis points in the target range at this meeting,” the record says, arguing that inflation had remained too high and that they saw few signs of it abating. A few others who backed the hold called the decision a close call. Many participants stressed that holding rates did not reflect a weakening of the committee’s commitment to returning inflation to 2 percent in a timely manner.
The key passage on the outlook:
“With regard to the outlook for monetary policy in the months ahead, almost all participants judged that, under their baseline outlooks for inflation and the labor market, further action to raise the target range for the federal funds rate — broadly consistent with the September Summary of Economic Projections — would likely be appropriate, in order to ensure a timely return of inflation to the 2 percent objective. A couple of participants noted that an increase of more than 25 basis points could warrant consideration at the next meeting if incoming inflation data were unfavorable.”
Related reading: our explainer on how the Fed sets interest rates
What the Fed Knew Then — and What Has Changed Since
The minutes are a snapshot of October 28: the Fed says their descriptions of economic conditions rest only on what the committee knew at the time. The October jobs, consumer price and producer price reports were all published after the meeting — and the new data mostly strengthened the hawkish case.
| Indicator | What officials knew on Oct. 28 | What we know now |
|---|---|---|
| Total PCE inflation (12-month) | 3.6% in September (staff estimate) | September figure stands; October PCE not yet released |
| Core PCE inflation (12-month) | 3.1% in September (staff estimate) | September figure stands; October PCE not yet released |
| Unemployment rate | 4.2% in September | 4.1% in October |
| Monthly payroll gains | About 50,000 a month, 3-month average to September | 165,000 in October |
| Consumer prices | September data only | October CPI: +0.4% in the month; core +0.3%, a third straight month at that pace |
| Producer prices | September data only | October PPI: +0.3% in the month; +6.5% from a year earlier, a four-year high |
Sources: Federal Reserve minutes, October 27-28, 2026; Bureau of Labor Statistics releases for October jobs, CPI and PPI. October figures were verified against the BLS releases — see our October CPI results article
The 50-Basis-Point Question
The question is whether the data since the meeting count as “unfavorable” — and on the evidence so far, the hawks have a case.
October consumer prices rose 0.4% in the month, with core prices up 0.3% for a third consecutive month — exactly the pace Governor Christopher Waller had flagged as the threshold for considering a half-point move. Waller repeated the case on CNBC on Wednesday, the day the minutes were released. Producer prices told a similar story, up 6.5% from a year earlier, the largest increase in four years. The labor market also looks firmer than the committee believed, with payrolls of 165,000 against a consensus forecast of about 65,000.
Futures markets, however, remain skeptical of the bigger move. CME FedWatch put the chance of a 25-basis-point December hike at about 95% and a 50-basis-point move at about 5%. The New York Fed’s survey of market participants, cited in the minutes, put the median expectation at one hike in December and another in March 2027, followed by a rate cut early in 2028.
A quarter-point move in December would lift the target range to 4.00%-4.25%, a midpoint of 4.125% — about 1.0 percentage point above September core PCE inflation of 3.1% (our calculation from the Fed’s own figures). A half-point move would widen that gap to about 1.5 points.
The AI Warning Buried in the Minutes
The most striking passage is not about rates at all. In the financial stability discussion, Fed staff highlighted the rapid growth of debt tied to the artificial intelligence buildout — off-balance-sheet leasing commitments and circular financing arrangements among AI firms that could amplify losses if returns disappointed.
Almost all participants commented on the risk that AI investment returns disappoint. Many weighed the consequences of an AI-related asset price revaluation, and most observed that AI-related debt had grown rapidly through complex and opaque financing structures. The staff judged elevated asset valuations and hedge fund leverage the most salient vulnerabilities, even as strong bank and household balance sheets provided a buffer.
Markets took the minutes largely in stride. The 10-year Treasury yield fell about 5 basis points to 5.06%, the 2-year yield slipped 1 basis point to 4.80%, the S&P 500 fell 0.3% to 7,321, and the Nasdaq 100 gained 0.4%.
The Case For and Against a Bigger Move
The case for 50 basis points rests on the data. Inflation on the Fed’s preferred gauge is 3.6%, 1.6 points above target; core inflation is stuck at 3.1%; the October CPI and PPI both came in hot; and the labor market is stronger than the committee thought. Some participants warned that delay risked entrenching high inflation, or requiring a larger and more disruptive tightening later.
The case against is about timing. The committee chose to accumulate more data before moving, and several participants argued a gradual approach would give businesses and households time to adjust. The December meeting also brings a fresh Summary of Economic Projections. And the November CPI is not due until December 10, the day after the meeting ends, so the October figures will be the final inflation reading officials have when they vote.
What to Watch Next
The December 8-9 meeting is now the main event, and it comes with updated projections showing how many hikes officials expect in 2027. Before then, the November jobs report will test the labor market, and the October PCE report will give the Fed its preferred inflation reading for the month that has already shaped the debate.
The minutes settle the direction: the Fed is still tightening, and the October pause was a pause. The open question is the size of the next step — and the data between now and December 9 will answer it. Our earlier coverage of the October decision
This article is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice.